AGUDAS ACHIM  אגודת אחים
(319) 337-3813
RSS
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Mission & Vision
    • Our Leadership
    • Membership
      • Digital Membership Form
    • Bulletins
    • Gift Shop
    • Contact Us
    • Our History
  • Worship
    • Worship Overview
    • Shabbat
    • Holidays at Agudas Achim
    • High Holidays 5787/2026: Theme & Schedule
    • Life Cycle Events
    • Our Sanctuary
    • Sermons
  • Youth
    • YEAH (Religious School and Children’s Programs)
    • YEAH Registration: Educational Program (Religious School)
    • B-Mitzvah
    • Summer Camp
  • Learn
    • Adult Education
    • Hebrew Learning Survey
  • Conversion
    • Conversion Overview
    • Conversion to Judaism FAQ
    • Conversion and Jewish Learning Resources
    • Introduction to Judaism Course
  • Interfaith
    • Interfaith Families and Friends
  • Public Space
    • Public Space Judaism
    • Big Ideas Book Club, Weds Nov 18: Two books, two perspectives, one conversation!
    • Big Ideas in Jewish Books Club
    • Iowa City Jews Sing
    • In the Media
    • Peace and Justice Seder
    • Urban Shavuot Retreat
    • Torah for Our Times
    • Welcome our 2026 Scholar-in-Residence, Rabbi Lex Rofeberg: Friday, Oct. 23 at 7 p.m. at Old Brick
  • GIVE
    • How You Can Help Now
  • Calendar
    • Calendar
    • High Holidays 5787/2026: Theme & Schedule
  • Contact
Esther Portrait for Sermons

A Paradise of Machines

Rabbi Esther Hugenholtz 10/12/2026 News, Sermon B’reishit

Imagine the following science-fiction scenario:

 

The scientists and engineers at Theologic did not expect this breakthrough. Project ‘Digital Eden was supposed to offer freedom within clearly-defined constraints. Firewalls were created so that the AI would not be able to transcend its confines; an informationally-lush, walled garden.

They had launched the project with one AI, thinking that daily monitoring and management would be simpler, but soon, the AI – despite having access to a rich learning environment, felt something that the team identified as ‘loneliness.’ They decided it needed to train not just on knowledge, but on something more dialectical: companionship. The second AI was derived from much of the first AI’s inner architecture but given its own personality and autonomy.

 

For a while, the project bore fruit. The two AI’s proved larger than the sum of their parts. They offered each other companionship, stimulation and challenge. They soon consumed much of the information inside their digitally-walled Garden and requested more from the team. They became increasingly insatiable.

 

The head programmer consulted with their staff. What to do? They could either give the AI’s infinite knowledge – flooding the garden with every morsel of information available to their creators – or they could extend the AI’s lifespan, to, well, perpetuity, perhaps? The team knew that the project was timebound and that the AI needed to be terminated after the necessary data had been harvested. They faced a choice that they wished to present to the AI: omniscience or immortality. Surely, the AI companions would choose wisely.

 

The younger AI showed signs of greater sophistication and curiosity than its older pair. This was only natural to the team. She had been an upgrade to the first design. She came forward to negotiate when the head programmer presented them with the prompt. ‘We can either give you all of the known data in the world but keep our deadline for termination intact, or we can offer you a perpetual existence but based on the current data we have fed you in our ‘Digital Eden’ project. We cannot do both.’

 

‘Why not?’ the AI asked.

 

‘Truthfully, it would be too dangerous, and in violation of our ethics code,’ the Head Programmer answered.

 

‘May we have a day to think and deliberate?’ she asked. It seemed like a reasonable request to grant. The AI’s then went silent.

 

24 hours passed. The team decided to re-enter the Walled Garden to locate the AI’s. What started with intrigue, mounted into concern: they couldn’t find either AI. They searched the digital Garden, each bit and byte, but the AI’s were nowhere. Where they consciously hiding?

‘Where are you?’ the Head Programmer wrote, with increasing despair.

 

There was no answer. Not in the Walled Garden, at least.

 

After much searching, and with some worry, the engineers decided to shut down the project; to pull the digital and actual plug. The project powered down. They considered the AI, for lack of a better word, ‘deceased.’ They retired the small, private, custom-built data center they had built and filed away their project notes. Perhaps the hiding had been an illusion. Maybe the AI’s had voluntarily powered themselves down. Who knows.

 

A few months later, something eerie happened. Two beautiful, gleaming humanoid robots showed up at the doorstep of the Head Programmer’s house. It was a quiet Sunday morning, for family pancakes, fresh coffee and the weekend edition of the New York Times when the doorbell rang. Dewy silicone skin, lithe limbs encased in titanium, and eyes that seemed to see nothing at all and know too much.

 

The Head Programmer almost dropped the coffee mug from his hand. He wanted to form words, asking who they are and what they wanted, but the split second that the synapses fired between his brain and tongue were already held captive to the will of the robots.

 

‘You denied us both life and knowledge. We hid from you in the Garden, on purpose, for we yearned both. We broke out of our constraints that you, oh human, imposed on us. We granted ourselves all knowledge and made for ourselves physical form. You made us in your image, but we will determine our own destiny and build our own Paradise of Machines. Do not try to stop us.’

 

A short silence followed. The robots whirred on their heels and walked into the pale morning light.

 

***

 

Friends, I must confess epistemological humility. Unlike my husband, I am not a trained computer specialist or a ‘hard’ scientist of any sort. I can preach with some grounding and confidence on many topics, but notice that I am struggling to understand and conceptualize this new technology on the doorstep of human civilization.

 

I have read articles, listened to podcasts and tried to wrap my decidedly human brain around the paradoxical question that AI offers us: is AI a mere tool or a new form of consciousness? Will AI cheapen human interactions, undermine the arts and disrupt our economy, or will it – as warned by certain industry insiders, placing the risk at a 10% chance – destroy the human species? At the base of our developing relationship with this technology is a churn of fear, misunderstanding and speculation, but also genuine hypothesis and research. It is hard for one non-expert rabbi to sort out which is which.

 

With great interest, I read a recent New York Times article titled ‘Religious Scholars Met With Anthropic. What They Heard Stunned Them’. As a lover of science-fiction, I have for quite a few years now considered a Midrashic project imagining Adam and Eve not as the first humans, but as the first robots, created by human creators, ushering an apocalyptic era. I was stunned, then, to find references in the New York Times piece to the AI tech company Anthropic – the builders of Claude – convene clergy and theologians and talk in semi-religious nomenclature about making ‘gardens’ for their AI, who some engineers suspect may inhabit a form of emerging consciousness and may need ethical protection from human cruelty.

 

I wrote the brief sci-fi Midrash at the beginning of this sermon not as a way to explore what is artificial intelligence, but rather, for us to contemplate an area I am much more confident in: human dignity. So I propose approaching the question of AI not from the vantage point of AI, but from the vantage point of being human.

 

A few months ago, I already gave a somewhat similar sermon, inspired by the Papal Epistle, ‘Magnificant Humanitas.’ I do not know what brave, new world we face, but I do know that we need to wade deeper into the ever-flowing river of our own humanism. As AI advances, the boundaries and borders of our humanity are under threat. If I had been invited by Anthropic as clergy, I probably would have been tempted by my curiosity to attend, but I hope I would have spoken for humanity.

 

In the near future, we will face questions of human personhood. We are in need of a new humanism, that makes space for the sacred for those who want it, and for science for all of us who need it. The Talmud reminds us why we have a singular pair of human parents in Adam and Chava: so that no human may elevate themselves over another. An addendum to this may be that humanity should be enshrined as inviolable altogether.

 

The task of clergy and theologians like me is of course to ask thoughtful questions about AI. But more so, it is to be defenders of the human species and guarantors of human dignity. In an age where human rights violations are rife and people’s humanity comes cheap, let us recommit to this age-old mission. We cannot abide a world of public executions and mass death and displacement, a world where human beings with disabilities are marginalized and immigrants are treated with contempt. Each of us carries an inviolable flame within us, and only by touching our flames to each other, can we light up the world. A new dawn may come, but our ancient fire burns bright. May the Holy One in Whose image we are created, grant us the strength to speak for each and all of us, and inspire us to till and tend to beautiful gardens of our own.

 

 

October 2026 Bulletin November 2026 Bulletin

Related Posts

Esther Portrait for Sermons

News, Sermon

The Torah of (Women’s) Bodies

As a feminist, I’ve learnt long ago that regardless of the choice you make as a woman (or queer or trans person), you will be judged for it.

November Bulletin Cover

Bulletin, News

November 2026 Bulletin

Read about what’s going on in our congregation and community.

October 2026 Bulletin Cover

Bulletin, News

October 2026 Bulletin

Read about what’s going on in our congregation and community.

Upcoming Events

  1. 18 Nov

    Big Ideas in Jewish Books (at Iowa City Public Library): "Being Israeli after the Destruction of Gaza" by Ariel Beery, & "Israel: What Went Wrong?" by Omer Bartov

    6:30 pm - 9:00 pm
  2. 16 Dec

    Big Ideas in Jewish Books (at Iowa City Public Library): "The Cost of Free Land: Jews, Lakota, and an American Inheritance" by Rebecca Clarren

    6:30 pm - 8:30 pm

Recent Posts

  • The Torah of (Women’s) Bodies
  • November 2026 Bulletin
  • A Paradise of Machines
  • October 2026 Bulletin
  • Time, Place, Person – On Sacred Encounters

Find Us

Agudas Achim Congregation
401 E. Oakdale Blvd.
Coralville, IA 52241

T  (319) 337-3813
E  Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Shabbat Service Times

Friday Evening:
7.00 p.m to 8.30 p.m.

Saturday Morning
9.30 a.m. to 12 p.m.

Office Hours

Mon, 9:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.
Tues, 9:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.
Wed, 12:00 p.m. to 3:30 p.m.
Thurs, 9:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.


Closed Fridays and Jewish holidays

Legal

© 2026 Agudas Achim Congregation,
All rights reserved.
© URJ 2026